Tuesday, 15 January 2013

Just Argue: Lady Gaga Takes on the Osbournes


I’m never Christmassing again. Two weeks into Blanduary and, already, I’m repenting every last sausage roll. Why is it that, year after sodding year, Saint Nick ambles out of town and we’re left holding the food baby? My qualms about December’s dumping ground don’t end with this new paunch I’m sporting, though, or with the China-sized hangover. Indeed, what riles me up most about the post-holiday blues is all this residue benevolence droll: it’s like last month’s peppy peace and goodwill, only it’s got all the pull and pizazz of Susan Boyle’s big toe. And it’s everywhere: only last week, I gave up a prime Sainsbury’s parking space because I couldn’t be doing with the bother of beeping my horn; Kat got practically let off her Derek-dalliance because Alfie just didn’t fancy the furore; and, most portent of all, the California Hamster Association have opted to forgive Justin Bieber for ill-advisedly giving his pet rodent to a fan, with a spokesperson clarifying that the organisation harbours ‘no ill will towards Mr. Bieber.’ I’ve seen bigger sparks fly in nunneries.
Who's laughing now? Kelly has made no secret of her dislike of Gaga's more zealous fans

Luckily, one story this week has dared to stick a middle finger to the slushy, sentimental drivel: the long running spat between Lady Gaga, the usual embodiment of studied nonchalance, and Kelly Osbourne, whose more recent public persona has been purged of pugnacity, has been reignited via a series of veiled online stings. It all started with the glitz of the 2012 Grammys last February, when Gaga, who was due to take to the stage for a rendition of her Marry The Night, snubbed the red carpet and its assembled paparazzi. Kelly, heading up E!’s Grammy Fashion Police coverage, was understandably a little miffed at missing out on the chance to pick apart Gaga’s tighter-than-George-Osbourne leather dress, and promptly took to the airwaves to criticise the Born This Way songstress. Regrettably for Kel (though less so for me and my current nice-nausea), Gaga’s so-called ‘Little Monster’ fans scuttled to her defence, beginning a barrage of abuse against Kelly and her comments. The tirade of tweets was pretty vile; amongst them were comments on Kelly’s weight and petitions for her to commit suicide. Since, understandably, she’s not spoken with cockle-warming love about La Ga’s extremist fans or the Lady herself, and the pair have traded catty asides on and off for nigh on a year.

Last week, Gaga once more entered the fray with an open letter to Kelly on her website. Jumping to her supporters’ aid following an interview in which Kelly once more told of their abuse, she wrote:‘While some of my fans have learning to do, most of them share the same values as I, and it's what bonds us together. And that bond is strong.’ Rather than using the note as an attempt to bury the hatchet, she opted to include digs at Kelly’s popular US show–‘I feel it culturally important to note that you have chosen a less compassionate path. Your work on E! with the Fashion Police is rooted in criticism, judgment, and rating people's beauty against one another’– and remind us all of why she, unlike Kelly, is a platinum reincarnation of Mother Theresa: ‘I choose to be positive and work towards a kinder and braver world with our community of followers.’
Force to be reckoned with: Sharon has waded into the row

What Gaga likely didn’t reckon on, however, was the repetition of a phenomenon X Factor producers were harping on about around about four months ago (and may well be again soon if recent Tulisa-less are to be believed): the return of the indomitable Sharon Osbourne. Not much of a wallflower type herself (she famously once boasted of how she would send packages of excrement to those who had dissed her family), Shaz quickly took Gaga to task with a public Facebook message: ‘I don't know what world you live in, but supporting disgraceful fan comments doesn't fall under the words "kinder and braver". It comes under the heading of bulls**t.’ Sharon admitted that she, not Kelly, had written to Gaga’s management over the pair’s feud, urging them to monitor the aggressive comments being directed to her daughter. She branded Gaga ‘a bully’ and dismissed accusations that Kelly had chosen a career that promotes negativity, writing simply: ‘Welcome to the real world.’ Gaga’s own Facebook account was updated shortly afterwards, with the star commenting: The "real world" can be cruel, why not try to change it into a better place? I am an activist. Nobody takes adolescents seriously, I do. My letter to Kelly Osbourne was open, because her statements on cyber-bulling were public & as a youth activist I'm compelled to be involved. It makes the Speidi/Rylan spat look like a kiss chase, really, doesn’t it?

Reviewing the blow-by-blow, I find it hard not to position myself firmly on Team Kelly (and that’s not just fear of receiving a Sharon poop-packet talking). First off, there’s Gaga’s sorry refusal to alienate her hardcore fans in spite of how many death threats they send. One can’t help but wonder, reading back over her letter, what it would take for the songstress to find fault with the people who buy her records. Their ‘bond’ might well be durable, but would such a self-dubbed ‘activist’ be so quick to excuse damnable tweets if they weren’t followed by the click of a download button? Then, as Sharon mentioned in her address, there’s Gaga’s astounding hypocrisy, not only in terms of condoning aggressive behavior whilst espousing anti-bullying laws, but also with regard to her entire public image. ‘Your show breeds negativity,’ she wrote to Kelly, ‘and over the years has even become comedic in nature. It glorifies you and Joan Rivers pointing in the camera, laughing, and making jokes about artists and celebrities as if we are zoo animals.’ This is coming from the woman whose more memorable outfits have included an ensemble made entirely of stitched-together Kermit the frogs, a cage headpiece (complete with chains), and that meat dress. Far from championing a life free from appearances, Gaga has founded her entire career on her appearance: Just Dance was forgettable; Pokerface downright bland; but everybody remembers the telephone-hat. Kelly, comedic? I guess that makes you Jack Whitehall, Gaga.
Not into appearances: Gaga at the 2010 MTV Video Music Awards

The little and monstrous amongst us might counter that Kelly’s cultivated a similarly superficial career. Did she not rise to fame off the back of her parents? Are her shapeshifting figure and chameleon-like hair changes not mostly responsible for her remaining in the public eye, along with (as Gaga pointed out) her part in a show fuelled by criticism? Maybe, but at least Kelly’s open and relatable when it comes to her looks: she speaks at length about her battles with the bulge in interviews and encourages healthy, balanced approaches to diets. When she’s sparring with a woman who chases outlandish, unobtainable styles and refuses to be interviewed without first being attended to by her bevvy of weirdo wardrobe assistants, Kelly seems about as vain as her mother is shy.

Either way, the duo has made my January a sliver more bearable. And where might it end? Picture it: Ozzy rehearsing off his best bat-biting snarl whilst Jack bungee-jumps into the fracas and Joan Rivers eyes up the ref. Or, perhaps more likely, a mightily peeved Gaga opening her morning mail…

UPDATE: Speaking to People magazine about Ga and their spat, Kelly revealed: 'All I have to say on this subject is that I love Lady Gaga! I made stupid mistakes when I was 25, as well, when I accused people of doing things that were wrong. We all live and we learn, and like I said, I'm a big fan of hers.'

February can't come quick enough.




No comments:

Post a Comment