Tuesday, 22 January 2013

Taylor Swift: I Remember When We Broke Up...Sort Of


Studying for a degree that demands six hours of reading for each hour of contact time, I’m no newcomer to procrastination. Until about ten days ago, in fact, I thought I’d seen every manner of dilly-dallying known to man, from the mildly remissible to the downright gratuitous (one chancer twice claimed the crumbs under the keys of his MacBook had made typing unthinkable). Last week, though, I unearthed a couple of avant-garde ways of not-working that I thought might just make it into time-wasting testaments everywhere. ‘It feels like the perfect night,’ warbles Taylor Swift on her latest album, Red, ‘to dress up like hipsters, and make fun of our exes, oh oh, oh oh’: surely better than fishing bits of bread out from beneath the spacebar, no? Alas, apparently not. Once I’d donned my best hipster garb (not my finest hour), it took me all of about twenty seconds to poke fun of bygone beloveds. Peeling off the tattered loafers and denim waistcoat (£3.75 I’m never getting back), I felt more cheated than R-Patz. What went wrong, I’m guessing, is the difference between what Tay-Tay and I would each thing of as ‘exes’. For me, it’s a pretty exclusive category: female prime-minister exclusive. For Ms. Swift, however, it’s a tad more inclusive.
Subliminal messaging: Taylor makes no secret of her quest for love

Taylor, now 23, strummed her way to UK favour in around 2008, long after trumping Shania Twain as the poster-girl for ‘country’ music in the States. Since, she’s stroked more chiselled chins than a Gillette advert. Kicking off with Joe Jonas, Taylor has enjoyed trysts with all-American teenagers Taylor Lautner and Connor Kennedy, as well as with the more seasoned Jake Gyllenhaal and John Mayer. Most recently, she’s rumoured to have parted ways with One Direction heartthrob Harry Styles (a Harry is for life, Taylor, not just for Christmas). What separates her from other young twenty-something serial daters, though, is that Taylor just doesn’t come across as the tarty type. Aside from the fact that her catalogue of former flames is more wholesome than an Abercrombie and Fitch campaign, there’s her instant affability (she’s the dorky-to-dream-girl type we all remember from school), her barefaced preference for commitment over steamy fumbles (‘He knelt to the ground and pulled out a ring and said…’), and her aversion to the rowdy melodrama of young celebhood (when Kanye West snatched her award away at the 2009 VMAs, she was gracious to the power of Kate Middleton). Indeed, it’s quite problematic to reconcile the weight of Taylor’s little black book tome with the somewhat diffident girl we get in interviews.
Coming on a little strong? Taylor has been known for her intense relationships

Whilst her good-girl image has thus far remained impervious to the string of Adonises (Adoni? See: procrastination), it seems progressively obvious that Taylor will soon have to compromise one or the other. First up, she said herself in an interview last October that she felt the level of pressure on her dating life was ‘abnormal…like a telescope lens’, and no wonder; with specific, often personal lyrics like ‘you made a rebel of a careless man’s careful daughter’, ‘what you’re looking for has been here the whole time’, and ‘today was a fairytale’, Taylor has never kept her love life off-limits. Second, there’s that giggling, gaggling core of schoolgirl fans, who no doubt want to see their spokeswoman get and keep the guy, and who can only be feeling a bit miffed that she keeps casting aside their pop-boy pinups. Then there’s Taylor’s own trepidation about coming to be known as LA’s answer to Katie Price (which probably wasn’t allayed at all when Selena Gomez recently branded her ‘experienced’), and the apparent effect it’s having on her ability to tie a guy down: rumours were rife that the split with Harry arose from her reluctance to, ahem, induct him into her hall of fame.
Exposure: Taylor sometimes encourages love-life attention

The snag, for Taylor, isn’t that she falls for guys fervently and frequently; her supposedly zealous, hard-and-fast attitude to love might be a little bunny boiler at times, but it’s surely preferable to the casual sexuality flaunted by the majority of her music-scene contemporaries. Plus, falling Swiftly doesn’t always mean falling stupidly (looking at you, Khlomar), and Taylor’s unbarred optimism makes her a much healthier role model than those who cultivate the screwed-up, contentious good-girl-gone-bad look. Where Taylor might be going wrong, instead, is the way she makes her private life more public than a Jubilee. Whilst penning (and even profiting from) tracks about teenage heartache might even be positive exposure for her fans, scrawling out numbers like Dear John mere weeks after ending it with Mayer and detailing specific breakups on chat shows (as Taylor has been known to do on The Ellen DeGeneres Show) might not be the wisest move for a girl keen to move away from documenting her high-profile dalliances. She can court and reject men all she wants, but when she courts media and fan speculation about those men, she’s asking for a messy breakup.

Taylor touched down in London earlier this afternoon, ready, people are either hoping or fearing (dependent on whether they’re a Taylorist or any other ten-year-old girl), for a ‘showdown’ and possible reconcilement with Styles. Whichever way it goes, let’s hope Taylor leaves this one off the next album; What Makes ME Beautiful might be a bit more than we can take.

No comments:

Post a Comment